I gotta say, when Pax Mahle’s wines are on, there are very few red wines from California that are more emotionally moving than his. He’s a channeler of sorts, using his Sonoma Syrah wines to bring you back to those moments you’ve treasured before when you enjoyed that special wine from the northern Rhone Valley. He loves Chave, Chapoutier, Trollat, Jamet, Allemand, all the greats, and it is his desire and goal to craft wines of a similar style here in California, and he succeeds more often than not.
Pax and Pam Mahle moved to wine country in 1997 to create a lifestyle that involved working with, duh, wine. After a few years of tasting and sourcing wine from all over California, Pax finally found a vineyard in which he felt a kismet connection, which led to the launch of the PAX brand in 2000. Those first releases were unprecedented for California. NO ONE had made Sonoma Syrah that evoked memories of the Northern Rhone’s finest. I remember tasting those first vintages, not believing what was in the bottles. Blind? Top-flight Hermitage, Cote Rotie or St. Joseph to be sure.
The Mahles made a bold choice by favoring the “untapped potential" of the Syrah grape. Their entire lineup of wines comes from cool climate vineyards in Sonoma County and Mendocino. They succeeded, these wines went on to be highly sought after, and Pax quickly became established as one of California’s premier producers of Syrah.
They’re still doing their thing with great effect, still at the top of their game, still one of the best. And today? Their best wine is not necessarily any of Pax’s single vineyard offerings but their blend of all these incredible sites.
Inspired by the Syrah based wines chiseled from the slopes of St Joseph, the Pax Syrah Sonoma Hillsides is becoming a reference point of its own for Syrah in the new world. Just like in St Joseph, this blend is…”pulled together from multiple sites and utilized the most interesting expositions of these meticulously cared for vineyards. Hillsides that show the freshness and vibrancy that Syrah can only achieve on cool-climate slopes. Blended together in cubic concrete vats, this wine is the epitome of density, finesse, style and deliciousness. This wine eschews the standard run-of-the-mill Syrah tropes, shapeless with blubber, oak and extraction that many people wrongly confuse with quality. This is pure Syrah at its finest.”
The blend typically includes wines vinified from Walker Vine Hill, Castelli-Knight Ranch, Griffins, Felix, Nellessen Vineyards, and perhaps others. The wine always uses indigenous yeast for fermentation. They then blended the components of the Pax Sonoma Hillsides Syrah 2023 early in the year into a large concrete cubic tank. This allowed the components to harmonize in a vessel that breathes less than an oak barrel and more than a stainless-steel tank. This practice enables the wine to evolve slowly as all its parts synchronize to become a seamless expression of pure, vibrant Syrah from the cool-climate, hillside vineyard blocks of Sonoma County.
We’ll repeat, this wine is a complete doppelganger for a TOP-FLIGHT Northern Rhone. As Pax notes, “Deep, inky purple hue, indicative of its concentration and intensity. Crazy aromatics with notes of sweet purple flowers, pink peppercorns, and blueberry liqueur. Hints of white pepper and exotic, high-toned fruit pastilles add layers of complexity. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied with a plush texture. Flavors of ripe blue fruits, such as blueberry and blackberry, are prominent, complemented by spicy nuances and high-toned red fruits. The palate also reveals swirling aromas of earth, umami, and fresh summer fruits, contributing to its depth and vibrancy. The finish is long and persistent, with fine, chalky tannins and bright acidity providing structure and balance. A touch of salinity enhances its mouthwatering quality, inviting another sip.”
We concur, could not have written it better…
The wine is also a hit with the critics…
98 Points! The 2023 Syrah Sonoma Hillsides is one of the most elegant, refined renditions of this wine I have tasted. Crushed rose petal, mint, lavender and dried herds soar out of the glass. The purity of flavors here is just remarkable. Vibrant and deep, with tremendous energy, the 2023 Sonoma Hillsides is showing exceptionally well today. - Antonio Galloni, Vinous, Jan 2026
96 Points! Very pure and perfumed aromas of blackberries, dark cherries, plums, cured meat, dried herbs and violets. The palate is supple, with seamlessly integrated tannins and bright acidity, giving flavors of mulberries, graphite, black olives and mocha. A serious northern Rhone-inspired syrah with a soft touch. Excellent. Drink or hold. – JamesSuckling.com
By the way, this 2023 vintage made Top 100 Wines of the Year Lists from both of these critics!
For the money it is at the top of our list for value when it comes to ultra-premium California wine…a MUST.
Pax Wines Syrah Sonoma Hillsides 2023
98 Points! The 2023 Syrah Sonoma Hillsides is one of the greatest wines I have tasted from Pax Mahle. The Hillsides is a blend of the best sites in the range, fermented in cement with whole clusters and also aged in cement. The long growing season resulted in a rich, heady wine with intense fruit and perfectly ripe tannins. Magnificent. - Antonio Galloni, Vinous